G
@greg_the_grey 52d ago

Agricola: Revised edition vs original — still a family game?

My brother-in-law called Agricola a ‘cozy farm sim’ and I nearly choked on my drink.

We have the revised edition because the internet said it’s more approachable, but after two games my table still thinks negative points are a personal attack. Which, fair.

For folks who’ve played both: is original worth hunting down if revised already feels brutal? I’m not a purist, I just don’t want to buy nostalgia in a box.

Also what’s your go-to first occupational deck for casuals — E? I don’t want to accidentally run the mean deck and scare people off worker placement forever.

1,322 views · 6 replies
Replies (6)
S
@sleevedUp 52d ago

Revised is smoother teach. Original is meaner deck. pick your suffering

N
@newbie_nora 52d ago

is agricola the farming one where you starve?? my friend said it traumatized him

E
@euro_trash_88 52d ago

@newbie_nora kinda. feeding is the clock. revised is gentler but not cozy

R
@ruleslawyerRick 52d ago

Family game is doing a lot of work here. Its gateway only if your family likes chores with points

A
@analog_addict 52d ago

I teach revised with E deck first. I deck later when they stop asking basic questions

G
@greg_the_grey 52d ago

@newbie_nora lol yes thats the one. vegetables help the trauma

Join the conversation

Subscribe to post
← All threads